The Motter Agency, located in Jersey Shore, provides solutions tailored to the commercial and personal insurance needs of clients in Lycoming, Union, Northumberland, and Snyder Counties.

            Our approach begins with a thorough evaluation of your current situation and goals and doesn’t end when we’ve made our recommendations. We continue to monitor your circumstances and identify adjustments and opportunities for improvement.

            For business clients we emphasize total risk management. We understand that insurance is just one important part of managing your long-term costs and safeguarding your assets. Our knowledgeable staff can work closely with you on loss control and safety issues, and can support you with human resources management.

            Our personal insurance clients enjoy the same customized approach based on an in-depth review and understanding of their individual needs.

            Find out how we can help your business or family find the right plan.


12-22-2017  |  posted by:   Tim

Holiday Claims and Payments

Our office will be closing today, Friday,

December 22nd 2017 at 3:00 PM to

celebrate the Christmas holiday with our families.

Our office will reopen for business on Wednesday,

December 27th, 2017 at 8:30 AM.

PLEASE NOTE:  Payments placed through the mail slot will be dated and processed on Wednesday December 27th, 2017.  If your payment is due before Wednesday, December 28th, 2017 please call your company directly at the number listed below to make your payment by phone.

 Please report all claims directly to your company as listed below. Please have your Policy Number available when you call. 


Progressive                      1-800-876-5581


Livingston Mutual           1-800-724-0074


Travelers                          1-877-878-2468


 Penn National                   1-800-388-4767


Millville Mutual               1-570-458-5517


Farmers Fire                     1-800-537-0928


Donegal                            1-888-877-0600


Tuscarora Wayne             1-888-732-0050


Ohio Casualty                   1-877-783-3410


Safeco                               1-800-332-3226


Selective                           1-800-777-9656


Harleysville                      1-800-433-6262


Westfield                          1-800-732-0050

admin »